If you loved Call of Juarez: Gunslinger for its fast six-shooter duels, comic-book narration, score-chasing gunplay, and unapologetically pulpy western tone, start with Evil West and Hard West 2. Evil West is the best replacement for explosive action, while Hard West 2 captures the gunslinger fantasy through turn-based tactics. Weird West, Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood, and Hunt: Showdown 1896 round out the strongest choices in 2026, each preserving a different part of Silas Greaves' appeal.
These aren't interchangeable recommendations. Gunslinger is a compact, linear FPS built around momentum: headshots refill your focus, dodges save you from ambushes, and the narrator's unreliable stories literally rewrite the level around you. The games below either preserve that speed, deepen the western role-playing, or deliver the same dusty tension from a completely different angle.
S-Tier: Evil West and Hard West 2
Evil West is the closest modern action substitute
Flying Wild Hog's Evil West replaces Silas Greaves with Jesse Rentier, a vampire hunter carrying a six-shooter, rifle, shotgun, and an electrically charged Rentier Gauntlet. The camera moves to third person, but the combat rhythm feels familiar: identify the dangerous target, interrupt it, and keep moving before the arena surrounds you.
The gauntlet is the key. Its pull lets Jesse drag smaller enemies into shotgun range, while the stun effect creates a clean opening for a melee combo. The Scorcher flamethrower handles clustered foes, and the Rentier Boomstick knocks back heavier targets. Against shielded vampires, don't waste pistol ammunition trying to chip through protection; use the gauntlet's crowd-control tools first, then punish the exposed weak point.
Evil West's 16-mission campaign is much more linear than Weird West, which makes it ideal if you want Gunslinger's immediate pacing rather than a sprawling RPG. Its weakness is repetition. Arena fights can recycle enemy combinations, and the upgrade tree occasionally makes the correct answer obvious. Still, at 60 frames per second on a modern PC, Jesse's dodge-cancelled melee strings feel wonderfully responsive.
Hard West 2 rewards the same quick-draw instincts
Hard West 2 is turn-based, but it understands the western gunfight better than many action games. You command Gin Carter and a supernatural posse across a campaign of train robberies, ambushes, and occult bargains. The defining mechanic is Bravado: killing an enemy refreshes a character's action points, allowing a well-planned chain of executions to turn a losing turn into a full-screen wipeout.
Gin's Deadman's Hand card lets her manipulate a shot's outcome, while Flynn's teleport ability enables the kind of sudden flank that Gunslinger players instinctively look for. Laughing Deer thrives at close range, where her melee attacks can trigger additional Bravado kills. Build around line-of-sight, elevation, and cover rather than simply giving every character the biggest damage weapon. A bad opening shot can strand your posse in the open, but a clean first kill can cascade through four or five enemies.
| Game | Best Match For | Combat Identity | Campaign Fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil West | Fast arcade shooting | Third-person guns and melee | Linear, 12–15 hours |
| Hard West 2 | Quick-draw tactics | Turn-based Bravado chains | Choice-driven, 25–35 hours |
| Weird West | Frontier role-playing | Immersive-sim combat | Open-ended, 20–40 hours |
| Bound in Blood | Classic Call of Juarez | First-person shooting | Linear, 8–10 hours |
| Hunt: Showdown 1896 | Online tension | PvPvE extraction shooting | Endless multiplayer |
For a deeper look at precision shooting design, Steamoz's Chaos Control rail-shooting tips are also worth reading, especially if you enjoy games that turn target priority into a score multiplier.
🎮 Call of Juarez: Gunslinger
Looking to experience this game? Grab your digital key directly on our store for $2.99.
View on Steammoz Store →A-Tier: Weird West and Bound in Blood
Weird West makes every frontier fight your own
Weird West is not a traditional FPS, but it may be the smartest recommendation here. WolfEye Studios' immersive sim follows five protagonists, beginning with bounty hunter Jane Bell and continuing through characters such as the Pigman, Protector, Werewolf, and Oneirist. Their stories overlap, and your decisions persist across the shared frontier.
Jane's campaign teaches the game's real strength: combat is about manipulating space. Shoot an oil lantern to ignite a group, kick an explosive barrel toward a barricade, use a fan to spread poison, or sneak behind an enemy and perform a silent takedown. Abilities such as Dash, Spirit Ward, and Homing can radically change an encounter, but ammunition remains limited enough that charging every room with a revolver is a bad habit.
The best early upgrade path is a practical one. Put points into Rifleman if you favor deliberate headshots, then take Nimble for mobility and utility skills that help you reposition. Keep a shotgun for close-range panic moments and a rifle for long sightlines. Unlike Gunslinger, Weird West doesn't constantly push you forward; it rewards scouting, saving often, and checking rooftops before entering a bandit camp.
Bound in Blood is the purest old-school follow-up
Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood remains the obvious choice if what you really want is another Techland western FPS. You play brothers Ray and Thomas McCall during the American Civil War and the years that follow. Ray is the aggressive bruiser, while Thomas emphasizes range, precision, and rope-based traversal. Several missions let you choose which brother to control, changing your weapons and approach.
Its shooting lacks Gunslinger's later polish, but the structure is right: short missions, explosive set pieces, mounted sections, duels, and a story obsessed with greed and betrayal. Ray's dual-wielding is effective at close range, while Thomas' rifle rewards slowing down and targeting enemies on elevated balconies. Don't expect modern aim assist or generous checkpoints. On PC, use a controller if mouse sensitivity feels erratic, and cap the frame rate if the old engine produces inconsistent timing.
Bound in Blood also provides useful historical context for Gunslinger. Silas' stories are exaggerated campfire myths; Ray and Thomas are messier, meaner, and more grounded. If you want the Call of Juarez name rather than merely a western aesthetic, this is still the safest pick.
B-Tier: Hunt: Showdown 1896 for multiplayer duels
Hunt: Showdown 1896 is the recommendation for players who remember Gunslinger primarily through its sound design and sudden stand-offs. Crytek's PvPvE shooter drops teams of hunters into Louisiana bayou compounds, where they track a boss, banish it, collect a bounty, and escape while other players close in.
The comparison stops at the six-shooters. Hunt is deliberately slow, lethal, and unpredictable. A Caldwell Conversion Pistol, Winfield M1873, or Sparks LRR can end a fight with one well-placed headshot, but every shot broadcasts your position. The Butcher, Assassin, and Spider are PvE threats, yet the most dangerous enemy is usually the hunter waiting outside the lair while your team burns through healing and ammunition.
Sound is your progression system. Crows, horses, broken glass, doors, and unsuppressed gunfire all create information. Move crouched when crossing a likely sightline, but don't crouch everywhere; slow movement makes you an easy target for a patient rifle user. Learn the difference between a Mosin-Nagant report and a Winfield burst, and you'll start reading the map before you see anyone.
| Playstyle | Best Pick | Core Weapon Approach | Main Warning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fast solo campaign | Evil West | Gauntlet into Boomstick | Enemy arenas repeat |
| Tactical planning | Hard West 2 | Bravado kill chains | Missed opener ruins positioning |
| Systemic sandbox | Weird West | Rifle, shotgun, environmental traps | Limited ammo punishes rushing |
| Classic western FPS | Bound in Blood | Ray's dual pistols or Thomas' rifle | Older PC controls |
| Competitive tension | Hunt: Showdown 1896 | Sound-aware loadouts | Permadeath-style hunter losses |
Before buying Hunt, check your hardware against Steamoz's Hunt: Showdown 1896 PC performance guide. The 1896 update can be demanding, particularly at 1440p with volumetric effects and high-quality shadows enabled.
Which Gunslinger features matter most to you?
The right recommendation depends on the specific part of Gunslinger you want back. If the fantasy is “walk into a room and delete six men before the soundtrack peaks,” choose Evil West. If it's the sensation of turning a bad ambush into a perfect chain of kills, choose Hard West 2. If you want stories that react to your decisions, Weird West is far more ambitious than Gunslinger.
Players chasing the original's historical western flavor should start with Bound in Blood, even if its age shows. Hunt is the long-term choice only if you're comfortable learning maps, losing hunters, and treating every sound cue as a tactical clue. It offers no cinematic story campaign to carry you through a weak match, but a successful bounty extraction creates the same breathless release as Gunslinger's best duels.
On PC, install the latest versions from the official Evil West Steam page, Hard West 2 Steam page, and Weird West Steam page. Verify controller support and ultrawide behavior before assuming every older western shooter will behave like a modern release.
Our final ranking for western action in 2026
S-Tier: Evil West is the best direct action substitute, while Hard West 2 is the most inventive tactical alternative. Both understand that a western hero should feel dangerous, not merely historically dressed.
A-Tier: Weird West delivers the deepest role-playing and the most memorable emergent encounters. Bound in Blood ranks here because its age affects controls and presentation, not because its campaign lacks personality.
B-Tier: Hunt: Showdown 1896 is exceptional but serves a narrower audience. It has the guns, mud, and suspense, yet none of Gunslinger's forgiving arcade momentum. For more settings-focused reading, Steamoz's Deadfall Adventures graphics guide is a useful companion when tuning an older western shooter.
Start with Evil West if you want an immediate, controller-friendly blast. Pick Hard West 2 if you want every bullet to matter. Either one preserves the essential Gunslinger feeling: a dangerous frontier, a loaded pistol, and one last impossible shot before the music kicks in.